Impact on Issues and Uncertainties

? Degree of influence of Russia on Turkey compared with Turkey’s perception of threat related to a Kurdish polity on its southern flank (near future critical uncertainty)
? Finding a compromise on Hezbollah and Iran presence or withdrawal from a future peaceful Syria (near future critical uncertainty)
? Are the root causes that allowed the Islamic State to rise in the region addressed (medium to longer term critical uncertainty)?

 ➄ to ➂ Constructive peace for Syria
Creation of a Federal Syria
 to  Survival of the Kurdish-led Federation of Northern Syria
  to  Middle East Tension

  Turkey’s perception of threat
➙ Threat to Israel

➚➚  Russia influence
➃ U.S. influence trial – likely leading to ➙➘ U.S. influence
➚ ?  U.S. Russia global tensions

?  Global spread “under cover” of Jihadism
➚ ?  Strengthening of al-Qaeda
➙ Resilience of Islamic State
➚ Convergence of al Qaeda – Islamic State

➙➘ Western NGOs and then businesses prospects in Syria

The Middle East various wars and crises are being progressively stabilised, as seen through the previous related signals over the last weeks. Meanwhile, the influence map in the region and worldwide is also being redrawn. There is still a long way to go to see a real constructive peace settling over the region. In the near future domestic governance, considering all actors, and delivering multidimensional security will be crucial. Probably terrorist attacks and tensions will flare up at times, but, nonetheless, stabilisation is at work.

For previous, related signals check the

Horizon Scanning Board

Syria is now the focus, as expected, with Syrian President Bashar al-Assad visit to Sochi and meeting with Russian Federation President Vladimir Putin on 20 November. Phone discussions between President Putin with the leaders of Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and, of course, the US, ensure that the major actors are not only consulted but also involved. This prepares the next step, which will be the 22 November tripartite meeting at leaders level on the Astana format (Russia, Iran, Turkey). Ministers of Foreign Affairs are preparing the meeting in Antalya. Meanwhile, Chiefs of Staff (military) will also meet.
Meanwhile, on 22-23 November a meeting of the “Er-Riyad opposition group” should take place in Riyadh, with a Russian presence through President Putin Special Representative Lavrentiev.

To start the 20 November meeting, President Putin stressed notably that he wanted to hear President al-Assad’s views on the organisation of the political process (that would lead to peace), including the holding of a People Congress (which is promoted by Russia, as Russia favours the establishment of a Federal Syria), and that these developments had to be made under the auspices of the UN.

Related in-depth analysis

Towards Renewed War in Syria? The Kurds and Turkey

“The Middle East Powder Keg and the Great Battle for Raqqa

Bashar al-Assad, thanking Russian efforts, confirmed his interest in a political process and that a National Dialogue Congress would be held.

This meeting and notably its content are thus a milestone, not only for peace in Syria, but also for a peace that will recognise the Kurds as well as other peoples and their specificities in Syria.  We may thus estimate that the likelihood to see a Federal Syria being reborn out of the destruction of civil war has increased.

The next challenges will be, on the one hand, to convince Turkey that this future Federal Syria, with an autonomous Kurdish-led Federation of Northern Syria is not a threat to its national security. On the other, a solution satisfying all actors will also have to be found as far as  the presence of Hezbollah and Iran within a future peaceful Syria is concerned, as was made clear by recent developments around  the Lebanese “Habibi crisis”.

Featured image: Syrian President Bashar al-Assad visits Russia on a working visit– 20 November 2017 – – C.C 0.4.


Syrian President Bashar al-Assad made a working visit to Russia

Vladimir Putin also introduced Bashar al-Assad to senior officials of the Russian Defence Ministry and the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces who were in Sochi to attend another series of meetings on military construction and the State Armament Programme.

Turkey, Russia, Iran to hold Syria summit

Hande Fırat – ANKARA Turkey, Russia and Iran will hold a high-level summit in Sochi on Nov. 22 to discuss the situation in Syria’s Afrin and Idlib regions, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has said, reiterated Ankara’s opposition to the invitation of the People’s Protection Units (YPG) to any meeting on the future of Syria.

Published by Dr Helene Lavoix (MSc PhD Lond)

Dr Helene Lavoix, PhD Lond (International Relations), is the President/CEO of The Red Team Analysis Society. She is specialised in strategic foresight and warning for national and international security issues. Her current focus is on the rise of China, the COVID-19 Pandemic, the methodology of SF&W, radicalisation as well as new tech and security.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.