Signals: Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Israel…

Impact on Issues and Uncertainties

? Unity of Arab States, willingness and capability to support Saudi Arabia, willingness and capability to counter growing Iranian influence, (critical uncertainties)

 ( conflict in Yemen) Saudi perception of Iranian expansion and resulting threat

➙ ? Lebanon destabilisation
  ? Hezbollah influence in Lebanon

➚➚ Iran actualization of the Shia crescent to the Mediterranean Sea
Iran influence

➚  Middle East Tension

➙ ? Russia influence
➙ ? U.S. influence
➙ ? France influence

Threat to Israel

Lebanon (ex?)-Prime Minister Hariri’s flight then resignation from Saudi Arabia has created a host of rumours, as actors try to understand what happened really. Irrespectively of the truth, the Hariri crisis has also generated – or revealed – potential for escalating tensions, centred this time around Lebanon, but that could impact the whole Middle East.

For other as well as previous and related signals check the

Horizon Scanning Board

The backdrop to the crisis is the redrawing of the influence map in the region as the political and geopolitical situation around Syria and Iraq change, moving from war to peace.

In a nutshell, we see a growing Iranian influence, Iran moving forward with the Shia crescent to the Mediterranean Sea, which is likely perceived as a threat by Saudi Arabia – and most probably Israel. The Saudi Kingdom’s threat perception can only be heightened by the latest explosion of a pipeline in Bahrain, and by a ballistic missile launched by the Iranian-supported Houthi in Yemen, which was destroyed close to Ryadh airport.

Iraq has moved under an Iranian sphere of influence, notably over the past month. If Russia notably would appear to guarantee a relatively future peaceful and non aggressive Syria, Iran will nonetheless have there a friendly future country. Thus, for those actors so inclined, Lebanon may be seen as the last place where to stop Iran’s ability to reach the Mediterranean Sea. There, under Saudi backed Prime Minister Hariri, the Shia Hezbollah had been able to increasingly participate in the Lebanese government. Hence one might conclude that the Saudis moved to derail Hezbollah and thus Iranian influence in Lebanon.

However, if such a move has taken place, it forgot to consider Lebanese wishes for peace and unity, and could actually, as a result, further increase the Hezbollah’s influence in Lebanon, as long as Iran does not make any vocal declaration nor acts in a way that could be perceived as more threatening by Saudi Arabia.

The international community is multiplying calls to calm and responsible behaviour.

Even though rash moves towards war are always possible, it may be difficult for Saudi Arabia to further escalate much the situation, despite war rhetoric, considering notably the Yemenite military quagmire, hence the need for support from other Arab States and the call for an extraordinary meeting of the Arab League. Saudi – and Arab – trade and aid sanctions on Lebanon could be imagined, yet they could also backfire, lowering Saudi Arabia’s influence in Lebanon. A return to the situation ante in Lebanon, with a shared influence, could be the ideal outcome of the crisis for all actors, including Saudi Arabia. In such a case, Iran would have succeeded in increasing its influence and actualizing its corridor or crescent to the Mediterranean Sea, however it would be kept in check by other powers, considering notably the Russian Hmeimim Air Base in Latakia.

In any event, Israel reasserted quickly its willingness and independence in defending its territory, wherever the threat could come from, also most probably to make sure that the promises by various larger powers such as the U.S. and Russia would be kept.

Arab League to meet on Iran at Saudi request: diplomats

The Arab League will hold an extraordinary meeting next Sunday at the request of Saudi Arabia to discuss “violations” committed by Iran in the region, according to a memorandum

In demanding Hariri’s return, Lebanese find rare unity

A country long divided by sectarian conflicts, Lebanon has found a rare point of unity since Saad al-Hariri’s shock resignation as prime minister: Lebanese of all stripes want him to come back from Saudi Arabia and to continue his work as premier.

Hariri warns Lebanon faces Arab sanctions risk, to return in days

Saad al-Hariri warned on Sunday Lebanon was at risk of Gulf Arab sanctions because of the Shi’ite group Hezbollah’s regional meddling and said he would return to Lebanon within days to affirm he had resigned as the country’s prime minister.

Israel signals free hand in Syria as U.S., Russia expand truce

JERUSALEM (Reuters) – Israel signalled on Sunday that it would keep up military strikes across its frontier with Syria to prevent any encroachment by Iranian-allied forces, even as the United States and Russia try to build up a ceasefire in the area. U.S.

Yemen’s Houthis fire ballistic missile at Riyadh

Yemen’s Houthi rebels have claimed responsibility for a loud explosion in Riyadh, saying they fired a long-range ballistic missile that travelled more than 800km over the border with Saudi Arabia. A spokesman for the rebels told Al Jazeera they launched a Burkan 2-H missile – a Scud-type missile with a range of more than 800km – towards Riyadh late on Saturday.

Signal: Al Qaeda / Islamic State New Front In Western Egypt?

Impact on Issues and Uncertainties

➚ ➃  Reinforced jihadist front in Western Egypt
  Challenges to Egypt as it is squeezed between the Sinai and Western fronts

  Survival of the Islamic State
  Islamic State resurgence in the MENA region, notably Libya
  Strengthening of al-Qaeda in the MENA region

  Reinforced linkages with other jihadist groups and theatre of operations in Africa

It would seem according to the array of indications included within the Reuters article below, that we are facing further spill over of the Islamic State conflict, as expected considering the Islamist Jihadist worldview.

For previous and other signals check the

Horizon Scanning Board

The likely spill over would be taking place in the western part of Egypt, and would originate geographically mainly from Libya and Mesopotamia.

We could have a possible strengthening of al-Qaeda affiliated groups and attacks, as fighters switch allegiance from the Islamic State, because of the latter current disarray in Mesopotamia. However, the Islamic State would also be showing some resurgence in Libya.

Related

Portal to Strategic Foresight and Warning Analysis for Libya (Scenarios, likelihoods, indicators, state of play)

The War against the Islamic State

We could witness both a competition for allegiance between the two nexus of jihadist groups and, on the ground, operational “temporary” alliances, as has already happened in the past in Libya.

Linkages with other jihadist groups and theatre of operations in Africa could also come to the fore.

Egypt Western Desert attack exposes front outside Sinai

A deadly attack on the police in Egypt’s Western Desert claimed by a new militant group risks opening up another front for security forces far beyond the remote northern Sinai, where they have battled a stubborn Islamic State insurgency since 2014.

Signal: Rival Libyan Governments Remain at Odds Over Haftar

Impact on Issues

/ ➄ Stalled peace dialogue / Continued war in Libya

On Monday, the head of the Government of National Accord’s (GNA) High Council of State—Abdulrahman Swehli—reiterated the continued inability of the GNA and the Council of Representatives (COR) to agree on General Haftar’s role in a united government.

For previous and other signals check the

Horizon Scanning Board

Swehli said that delegations from both governments have mostly agreed on a new government structure to rule the country until 2018 elections, with the exception of military control and Haftar’s role. “The obstacle now is mostly about the military and how it will be run and who will be in control,” Swehli said. “The other side is very clear that they want to carry on with what they have at the moment, which is not good for our democracy. We are still far away from each other.”

The Council of Representatives based in eastern Libya continues to align itself with General Haftar and demand that he have a leading role in the new Libyan state.

Related

Portal to Strategic Foresight and Warning Analysis for Libya (Scenarios, likelihoods, indicators, state of play)

Haftar’s polarizing politics and tactics remain a principal source of contention between Libya’s various factions, which undermines any dialogue about his potential role in a united government.

Considering Haftar’s pursuit for power, the COR’s refusal to align with a government that excludes him, and the GNA’s demand that he recognize their authority and submit to civilian control, it’s likely that Libya will continue on the path of political separation and conflict.

Libyan rivals split over army leadership: Tripoli parliament head

TRIPOLI (Reuters) – Libyan factions involved in U.N.-brokered peace talks are still far apart on the issue of the leadership of a future national army, the head of one of two rival parliaments said on Monday.

The Paradox of U.S. Decline … and the Tensions with North Korea

This article stresses the paradoxical character of a U.S. decline, and addresses the impossibility for the U.S. to accept its demise as superpower. It applies this framework to the case of the 2017 tensions with North Korea, and deduces a possible future path for the U.S. course of action, as well as possible levers regarding the U.S. stance.

It is the last part of a series of three articles where we examine three dimensions of U.S. decline as perceived – publicly – by the U.S. National Intelligence Council (NIC), part of the U.S. Office of The Director of National Intelligence (ODNI). In the first part (open access), we sought to understand what the NIC means exactly by a U.S. decline and its onset. The second article focuses on the sources of American decline and power, as identified by the NIC, which also give us indicators to monitor the decline.

Executive Summary

When decline of a country is the issue, the perceptions and resulting actions of the declining power are crucial. Therefore, we focus upon the way the U.S. Intelligence Community (I.C.) addresses the idea and reality of an American decline, through the unclassified (public) version of Global Trends: The Paradox of Progress (GT), the Quadriennal Strategic Foresight report the U.S. I.C. produces for the new President elect.

Because of GT’s uncertainties, ambiguity, indeed a paradox regarding the U.S. decline, results. On the one hand, decline is asserted but with implicit uncertainties, and, on the other hand, ways to revert it are also suggested. Furthermore, the U.S. I.C. also stresses the unique moral place of the U.S. in the world. As a result, the foresight report could finally prompt and support not acceptance of the end of the U.S.-led unipolar world, but the design of a very assertive U.S. policy to regain or keep superpower status, which it is a moral duty to follow.

There is here convergence between the assessment of the U.S. I.C. and the Trump presidency’s “America First” policy. Isolationism is not part of the picture, despite some commentators’ initial hasty conclusions, just after the elections.

When applied to the 2017 North Korean crisis, the framework constructed by GT explains the U.S. stance. It shows it is likely that the crisis has also become a stake in the U.S. struggle for recovering or maintaining its superpower status. As a result, there is a high probability to see the U.S. remaining locked into its escalating stance, even though diplomacy is also used behind the scenes, should a face-saving path forward for the U.S. not be found and used.

Meanwhile, by choosing this direction towards power, the U.S. could lose sight of its very security, which could, in turn, favour and potentially hasten decline, hence the paradox.

Full article 2547 words – approx. 7,5 pages

Access for non-members or for your package is limited.
To continue reading, become a member of The Red (Team) Analysis Society.
If you are already a member, please login (don’t forget to refresh the page). 

If you want to read free articles, look for our open access publications.

* It is crucial never to forget the importance of morality in American foreign policy, e.g. Robert W. McElroy, Morality and American Foreign Policy: The Role of Ethics in International Affairs, Princeton University Press, 1992.

——–

About the author: Dr Helene Lavoix, PhD Lond (International Relations), is the Director of The Red (Team) Analysis Society. She is specialised in strategic foresight and warning for national and international security issues.

Featured image by tammyatWTI, Public Domain, Pixabay

——–

Detailed bibliography

Adizes, Ichak Kalderon, “The Decline of the United States“, The WorldPost, Berggruen Institute and The Huffington Post, 15 May 2015

Chinese Foreign Ministry,  “Foreign Minister Wang Yi spoke with German Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Gabriel“, August 15, 2017.

Etzioni, Amitai “Is America Losing Its Credibility with the Middle East?”, 26 October 2017, The National Interest

Harvard Thucydides’s Trap Project

 Mohammed Arshad, and Matt Spetalnick, “Exclusive: U.S. pursues direct diplomacy with North Korea despite Trump rejection“, 1 November 2017, Reuters

National Intelligence Council, Global Trends: The Paradox of Progress (GT)Office of the Director of National Intelligence, (for the public version, January 2017).

Reuters, “Merkel suggests Iran-style nuclear talks to end North Korea crisis“, 10 Sept 2017.

Reuters, “Trump’s threat to ‘destroy’ North Korea is wrong: Merkel“, 20 Sept 2017).

Waltz, Kenneth, Theory of International Politics, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, 1979.

Read a summary of Waltz’s theory in the Korab-Karpowicz, W. Julian, “Political Realism in International Relations“, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2017 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.).

Xinhua, China, Russia, South Korea urge caution with DPRK at UN assembly, Global Times, 22 Sept 2917.

Signal: Still no Agreement – Iraqis Forces and Peshmergas

Impact on Issues and Uncertainties ➚ ? ➃  Short term – Willingness of Iraq to capitalize further on their military victory against the Kurds, notably capturing Kurdish oilfields (uncertainty)➘ ? Medium to longer term – capacity of Iraq to govern legitimately over its multi-sectarian multi-ethnic population (critical uncertainty) ➚ ➃  /➄ Iraq strength and international support ➘ ➂ Legitimacy of Iraqi Kurdish political authorities and parties➘ Prospects for Iraqi Kurds’ independence and even autonomy ➙ ➃  Iran’s influence in Iraq and in the region ➘ ➃  U.S. influence in the region➘ Middle East American order (Other issues stable as regard to this signal only – a full assessment would need to consider events in Lebanon and Yemen) On 5 November 2017, the ongoing negotiations between the Iraqi forces …

The remaining part of this article is for our members and those who purchased special access plans. Make sure you get real analysis and not opinion, or, worse, fake news. Log in and access this article.

Event – Book Launch / Lancement “Géopolitique d’une Planète Déréglée”

Bilingual text EN-FR – Invitation to book launch, then presentation of Dr Jean-Michel Valantin, Géopolitique d’une Planète Déréglée.

Buy on Amazon

English invitation: Join us on 7 Novembre, 19h15 for Dr Jean-Michel Valantin Géopolitique d’une Planète Déréglée book launch, at Sciences Po, 13 rue de l’Université, Amphi Erignac, with a debate on “current geopolitics and the Anthropocene” (see more detail – Fr – here) – Free entry.

Invitation française: A l’occasion de la sortie du livre de Jean-Michel Valantin, Géopolitique d’une Planète Déréglée, nous sommes heureux de vous inviter à un débat sur “la géopolitique contemporaine à l’heure de l’Anthropocène”, mardi 7 novembre à 19h15 à Sciences Po (13 rue de l’Université, Amphi Erignac). Animé par Fanny Agostini (Thalassa, France 3), il réunira Jean-Michel Valantin (spécialiste de géopolitique, responsable « Environment and security » de The Red (Team) Analysis Society) et François Gemenne (Directeur du programme “Politique de la Terre à Sciences Po-USPC et auteur du livre Géopolitique du climat, Colin, 2015). Entrée gratuite.

Dr Jean-Michel Valantin, head of the Environment and Geopolitics Department of The Red (Team) Analysis Society, launches his new book Géopolitique d’une planète déréglée (Le Seuil).

The book focuses on the current geophysical and biodiversity crisis, which is quickly and massively disrupting modern geopolitics, through wars, massive refugee crisis, the international competition for resources, and the weakening of national security systems.

Where are we heading as a result from the US, Russian, Chinese policies and strategies? What are the geopolitical and strategic consequences of the warming, overexploitation and pollution of the ocean, especially in the Arctic? Is the Somali piracy a possible future scenario for other places? Which regions and countries will be best prepared to face these future shocks and how will they handle them?

The author, specialised in strategic studies and defence sociology with a focus on environmental geostrategy, addresses these crucial issues and warns us about the growing danger of “a resource and climate war of all against all”, which it is still possible to prevent.

Dr Jean Michel Valantin, qui dirige la section Environnement et Géopolitique de The Red (Team) Analysis Society, présente son dernier livre: Géopolitique d’une planète déréglé (Le Seuil).

Les changements géophysiques et la crise biologique planétaires en cours sont autant de facteurs de bouleversements géopolitiques rapides, massifs et brutaux. Un nouveau paysage géopolitique et stratégique émerge, marqué par la combinaison du changement climatique et de ses effets systémiques, telles les migrations de masse, la compétition mondiale pour les ressources et la crise des régimes contemporains.
Où les politiques des Etats-Unis, de la Russie et de la Chine mènent-elles la planète ? Comment l’épuisement des océans alimente-t-il la piraterie maritime ? Comment le réchauffement de l’Arctique est-t-il exploité par certains intérêts tandis qu’il constitue une immense catastrophe pour des milliards d’humains ? Quelles régions ont-elles les meilleurs atouts pour traverser le XXIe siècle ? L’auteur, spécialiste de géopolitique, nous fait comprendre les liaisons dangereuses entre puissance économique, guerre et environnement. Il nous alerte sur les dangers, les violences et les barbaries qui se profilent.
Le moment du choix collectif entre la « guerre de tous contre tous » sur une planète effondrée ou une alliance stratégique mondiale pour répondre aux nouveaux défis planétaires approche à grands pas.

—–
Jean-Michel Valantin, PhD in strategic studies and defense sociology, head of “Environment and Geopolitics” of The Red (Team) Analysis Society), is also the author of Hollywood, Washington et le Pentagone (Autrement, 2003), Écologie et gouvernance mondiale (Autrement, 2007) et Guerre et Nature, L’ Amérique se prépare à la guerre du climat (Prisma Media, 2013).

Signal: Google Alphabet CEO Thinks China will Lead in AI by 2025

Impact on Issues and Uncertainties

Will the U.S. be able to stem this declining tide in terms of AI? How threatening will the leadership of China in terms of AI be perceived? what would mean escalating tensions between China and the U.S. involving AI and how would they play out? (Critical uncertainties)

➚➚ China influence

China rise to top major power status

U.S. influence
➚➚ US decline to major power status

Escalating Tension U.S. – China

Eric Schmidt, Executive Chairman, Alphabet Inc. (Google) and Chair, Defense Innovation Board, stated he believed that:

“These Chinese people are good… It’s pretty simple. By 2020, they will have caught up; by 2025, they will be better than us; and by 2030, they will dominate the industries of AI.” (Eric Schmidt, Artificial Intelligence and Global Security Summit, CNAS, 1 Nov 2017)

Meanwhile, he praised the capacity of China to develop a national strategy with corresponding public funding to reach this aim, whilst contrasting the inability of the U.S. to have such a national and collective purpose.

Considering the growing emphasis on artificial intelligence globally, its exponential integration within all devices across sectors, from civilian including finance to military domains, a Chinese leadership in AI then dominance would most probably further consecrate the decline of the U.S. to the status of a major power among others.

Early signals of this American loss of power in terms of science, innovation and technology have been apparent since at least December 2014 (see 11 December 2014 Weekly Scan, “The U.S. under Threat”).

Will the U.S. be able to stem this declining tide? Which strategies will the various actors concerned deploy? What will be the political and geopolitical impacts not only of this increasingly obvious American decline but also of Chinese highly possible dominance in terms of AI, among other technological developments? How threatening will the leadership of China in terms of AI be perceived? What would mean escalating tensions between China and the U.S. involving AI and how would they play out?These are critical uncertainties that must be part of our agenda.

Google Chairman: China Will ‘Dominate’ US in AI By 2030

Eric Schmidt, the top dog at Google’s parent company Alphabet, warned that China was on track to surpass the US in artificial intelligence by 2025 and to ‘dominate the industry’ by 2030 – unless American minds change their approach. The comments came in response to Beijing outlining their artificial intelligence strategy.

Signals: Russia, Iran, Turkey – A Syrian Strategic Triangle

Impact on Issues and Uncertainties ? Degree of influence of Russia – and now possibly Iran – on Turkey compared with Turkey’s perception of threat related to a Kurdish polity on its southern flank (critical uncertainty) ➚➚ ➃ Turkey’s perception of threat ➚➚➚ ➃ to ➂ Survival of the Kurdish-led Federation of Northern Syria➚➚ ➄ to ➂ Constructive peace for Syria ➘ ➃ to ➂ Middle East Tension➚ Iran influence➚➚ ➃ Russia influence➘ Threat to Israel➚➚ ➃ U.S. influence trial – likely leading to ➘➘ U.S. influence ➚➚ ? ➁ U.S. Russia global tensions ➘ Western NGOs and then businesses prospects in Syria On 1 November 2017, the President of the Russian Federation Vladimir Putin and the President of Islamic Republic of Iran Hassan Rouhani met in Teheran.For previous and other signals check the Horizon Scanning BoardFriendly statements followed. Iran …

The remaining part of this article is for our members and those who purchased special access plans. Make sure you get real analysis and not opinion, or, worse, fake news. Log in and access this article.

Everything you Need to Know to Understand the Islamic State’s Terrorist Attacks, Cope … and Fight Back

Whatever way one wants to see it, despite defeats in Syria, Iraq, Libya, and the Philippines, the Islamic State has not disappeared and will most probably remain a feature of our world for some times.

The regular terrorist attacks taking place throughout the world are there to remind us that to win over ideas – and the actions they prompt, a comprehensive strategy mirroring and superseding the strategy of the enemy must be designed and implemented.

Until then terrorist attacks will continue, as the 2017 Halloween attacks in New York in the U.S. and in Kaboul in Afghanistan show (Gina Cherelus, Daniel Trotta, Reuters, 31 Oct 2017; Reuters, 31 October 2017).

It is thus twice crucial to understand what is behind these attacks: to possibly counter them while withstanding them at best as long as real victory has not taken place.

Here is what you need to know to understand, cope, and possibly fight back the Islamic State terrorist attacks (with proper references, as we are in the realm of knowledge and not opinion here).

This compendium includes 11 selected articles – i.e 40733 words /  114,5 pages.

You can read freely below a short presentation of each article, and access the complete articles by becoming a member of the Red (Team) Analysis Society (quarterly, biannually or yearly subscription available).

On terrorist attacks more specifically

The Psychological Impact of the Islamic State Terrorist Attacks

Here we focus on the major socio-psychological consequences of terrorist attacks. We first explain the disconnection existing between direct exposure to the attack, objective threat and socio-psychological impacts, i.e. how people are impacted psychologically even though they are not in the immediate vicinity of the attack and how this phenomenon takes place. This will allow us better envisioning who can be impacted. We then turn to the more individual harmful psychological consequences of terror attacks, from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) to depression and insomnia and their impacts on businesses through impaired professional life. This will notably allow us pointing out that a crucial stakeholder for the corporate sector in terms of considering the Islamic State’s and Jihadist terrorist attacks and thus related geopolitical uncertainties is the department of human resources, which must thus be primarily involved, besides other more obvious departments such as security, risks, or sales, marketing, operations and finance. Staff in charge of exports and supplies must also become involved as the companies with whom they are dealing could be impacted by terrorist attacks. Finally, we shall turn to socio-psychological consequences with collective impacts, which have various effects on companies and de facto societies and countries, from avoidance (not doing something anymore, e.g. flying, traveling by train, visiting some countries, investing in some sectors and countries, etc.) to the rise of collectively aggressive behaviour…. read more.  4580 words / 12 pages.

Overcoming the (Western) mental confusion and trap when dealing with Islamist Terrorist attacks

Fighting the Islamic State’s Terrorism at Home – The Third Way” to be able to “Truly defend… and Strike Back

These two articles address the continuing and appalling confusion existing notably in Western countries when Islamist terrorism is at stake.  In the midst of the caricatural debate according to which we would have the choice only between hiding the Salafi character of these terrorist attacks because they would be understood as “Islamophobia”, on the one hand, or focusing on immigration mainly as a universal panacea, on the other hand, French terrorist prosecutor Molins shows us the way forward towards finding a new and third way.  We must assess coldly the threat first with all its components, before to look for solutions second. Fighting the Islamic State’s Terrorism at Home – The Third Way (the assessment  3585 words / 10 pages) and Truly defend… and Strike Back” (possible ways forward – 3137 words / 10 pages) are a contribution to this endeavour.

The Islamic State and Terrorist Attacks: License to Kill

In the light of the ongoing terrorist attacks, it is crucial to understand the perspective and position of the Islamic State as far as these attacks are concerned. This is what this article does. It thus  defines the framework for the Islamic State’s – and its members’  intentions, as well as  identifies sensitive points in terms of legitimacy. From there, we may notably deduce a number of elements and factors that could be useful, in particular to intelligence services and political authorities, to screen and prioritize entities that could be, or not, possible targets, and to identify potential new threats. Conjointly, sensitive points, and discrepancies in messages, may also be used, as we shall point out at the end of the second part and in the third part below, to craft counter-psyops, counter-radicalisation and even psyops messages… Read more. 3463 words / 10 pages.

The Islamic State’s permanent all out war

The terrorist attacks of the Islamic State can only be understood if one, first, makes the effort to change one’s perspective to see the world through the eyes of the Islamic State. It is this vision that underlays the attacks. This does not mean accepting or legitimating the Islamic State. It means using good red teaming analysis, and taking the measure of the enemy … to win.

 “Worlds War

Using material from the Islamic State propaganda, we address, first, doubts and denials that were aired following the Paris attack, notably in the media and general public, and which tend still to inform the general misunderstanding on the Islamic State, regarding the reality and nature of the war with the Islamic State. We then turn to the Islamic State and its Khilafah to better understand their perception of the political order and of the related entities they are creating, or had created, and finally consider a first impact of that vision and related actions, an assault on modernity, and what that means in terms of responses…. Read more.  3468 words / 10 pages.

Ultimate War

This is the second part of our analysis of the Islamic State’s worldview and of its impact.

We first show that the Islamic State’s belief-system deeply questions and changes the perception of what is domestic and what is foreign, then that it destroys the very notion of civilians and non-combatants. We then draw conclusions regarding the type  of war that is emerging as a result of the Islamic State’s Weltanschauung (German philosophical concept referring to the deep underlying conception of the world held by one or many actors) – with potential tremendous impact for us in terms of vision, strategy and warfare – knowing that those findings will need to be refined and eventually revised as the war unfolds and as actors evolve and change…. read more. 4291 words / 11 pages.

The global perspective of the Islamic State and its impacts

The global perspective of the Islamic State demands that we understand the Islamic State fight in a global way. It is neither limited to a war that would be classically understood, nor to a specific bounded territory, e.g. Syria, Iraq, Libya etc.

A Global Theatre of War

After the Winter 2015 strings of terrorist attacks, it had become even more obvious than previously that the Islamic State fights globally. This article suggests that one also needs to integrate a global geographical level to our response to correctly fight the Islamic State. First, we recall that the Islamic State and its Khilafah are inherently a global warrior polity, thus aiming at operating globally. Second we look at what we knew of the capacity of the Islamic State in November 2015 to reach out globally, and underline dynamics operating between different components of this capability. Even though the capabilities of the Islamic State have now changed and been seriously reduced, the understanding and dynamics at work are still valid and must be considered. Finally, we turn to the last element of the very capacity to act globally, the scope of the Islamic State global imprint…. Read more.  4003 words / 12 pages.

Early warning… “The Islamic State, from the Philippines and Indonesia to Bangladesh

This article ends the part of our series singling out risks to a strategy that would only or mainly pay attention to one theatre of war and to one dimension and focusing on the Islamic State global geographical implantation. It looks at then maybe less known cases of global outreach for the Islamic State and its Khilafah: Malaysia and Indonesia, as well as the Philippines in SouthEast Asia and Bangladesh in South Asia. This article written in January 2016 constitutes an early warning for the siege of Marawi in the Philippines, which took place over the Summer and beginning of Autumn 2017, as well as for the increasing imprint of the Islamic State there, for example. … Read more.  3525 words / 10 pages.

But who carries out the terrorist attacks and why? Why do Asian and European citizens join the Islamic State?

 A threat when returning… but also when staying

We explain the risks entailed by the existence of and increase in mobilization abroad, or, more specifically, outside the territory the Islamic State rules or has conquered. This inflow of foreign fighters can be seen as a security issue for three major reasons. First, it enhances the Islamic State’s fighting power. Second, it leads to a threat to see attacks carried out at home by those foreign fighters, not only once they come back, but also if they are stopped leaving. Finally, the symbolic impact of a successful foreign mobilization interacts with the connectedness of each mobilised foreign individual to enhance the power of the Islamic State psyops and potentially intensify the first two elements of the threat…. Read more. 2989 words / 9 pages.

How and why the Islamic State attracts “foreign” fighters

“Attracting Foreign Fighters” (Part 1)

We first present the set of Islamic State psyops “recruitment” products used, notably initially before a crackdown took place on social networks and before the Islamic State lost in Mesopotamia. We then turn to the framework for understanding established by existing research. We then focus upon two necessary elements that were identified as present in most or all fighters that were recruited: a quest for purpose and meaning, as well as a search for belonging. Those elements are at the core of a first complex around which messages and features favouring mobilization are organised and that we shall detail with the next post, which will also focus on the second complex, organised around the theme of authority, rules and exercise of liberty…. Read more. 3661 words / 10 pages.

“Foreign Fighters’ Complexes” (Part 2)

This article further refines, always using the Islamic State recruitment psyops products, the various elements identified by previous research, which we understand as organised in two complexes*, the first constellated around the core “quest for meaning and related need for belonging”, and the second around authority, rules and exercise of freedom…. Read more. 4031 words / 10,5 pages

Signal: Russia to Support Deeper Involvement of Kurds in Post-War Syria

Impact on Issues and Uncertainties ? Degree of influence of Russia on Turkey compared with Turkey’s perception of threat related to a Kurdish polity on its southern flank (critical uncertainty) ➚➚ ➃ to ➂ Survival of the Kurdish-led Federation of Northern Syria➚ ➃ Russia influence trial As the seventh round of Astana talks proceeds (30 Oct-31 Oct 2017), Russia’s envoy Alexander Lavrentyev stated:“The question arises on how to involve the Kurds more actively in the post-conflict restoration and political resolution.”This statement, as well as the federal design for Syria Russia favours,  would let us expect that Russia will support the Kurdish led project, i.e. to see their Federation of Northern Syria within a united Syria survive and strive. As a result, the survival of the Kurdish-led project …

The remaining part of this article is for our members and those who purchased special access plans. Make sure you get real analysis and not opinion, or, worse, fake news. Log in and access this article.

EN